If you are comparing kit homes vs granny flats, the biggest difference is that they describe two different things.
A kit home is generally a way of supplying and constructing a building, while a granny flat is a type of self-contained dwelling. For a Sydney or NSW homeowner, that distinction matters because the planning rules, site requirements, construction process and long term use can be very different.
At Brickwood Homes, we often speak with homeowners who start their research looking at different types of backyard houses and then find themselves comparing kit homes with professionally built granny flats. It is an understandable comparison, especially when you are trying to work out what will make sense for your block and budget.
In this guide, we’ll break down the differences without getting buried in building jargon, so you can get a better idea of which option suits your property, your family and your plans for the space.
What is the Difference Between a Kit Home and a Granny Flat?
A kit home usually refers to a home supplied as a package of components that are transported to the site and assembled or constructed there. The exact inclusions, construction method and level of finishing can vary between suppliers.
A granny flat, on the other hand, refers to a self-contained secondary dwelling associated with a principal home. In NSW, a granny flat can be within, attached to or separate from the main dwelling, provided the relevant planning requirements are met.
That distinction is worth keeping in mind because you are not always choosing between two directly equivalent products. You may actually be choosing between a particular construction approach and a particular type of dwelling.
See Brickwood Homes’ range of granny flats.
Which Option Gives You More Design Flexibility?
Let’s compare the two in terms of design flexibility:
Kit homes can work well for a defined design

Kit homes can appeal to homeowners who already have a fairly straightforward idea of what they want and are comfortable working within the supplier’s available designs and specifications.
The catch is that your block still has to work with the design. A house that looks perfectly suitable in a brochure may become much harder to use on a narrow block, a sloping site or a property with awkward access.
Granny flats can be designed around the block

With a professionally designed granny flat, the starting point is usually the site and how you intend to use it.
At Brickwood Homes, we offer different granny flat floor plans and can also work with homeowners who need something more tailored. That can be particularly useful when the backyard has an unusual shape or you want the new dwelling to sit comfortably alongside the existing house.
For example, a family in Western Sydney might want two bedrooms for an older parent and occasional guests, while another homeowner may care more about creating a private rental space. Those two projects may need very different layouts even if the buildings are similar in size.
Which is Easier to Get Approved in NSW?
This is one area where it pays to be careful with broad claims because approval depends on the property, zoning, proposed development and the pathway being used.
In NSW, a granny flat may be eligible for approval as a complying development if it satisfies the applicable standards. Otherwise, a development application may be required. The NSW Planning Portal explains that a complying granny flat must be associated with a principal dwelling and be on the same lot.
The important point is that buying a building package does not remove the need to consider planning and building requirements.
At Brickwood Homes, we investigate the site and help manage the approval process as part of the build journey, which can take some of the uncertainty out of getting started.
How Much Does It Cost to Build a Granny Flat Compared With a Kit Home?
There is no useful single price that applies to every property. Site access, ground conditions, services, design, finishes, approvals and the amount of work required can all affect the final cost.
That is why every potential homeowner should be cautious about comparing a kit home’s advertised starting price with a granny flat quotation and assuming the cheaper figure will stay cheaper once the project is complete.
If you are researching how much to build a granny flat, look at what is actually included in the quoted price and whether site related costs are accounted for.
Which Option is Better for Long Term Use?
For many homeowners, the answer comes down to how they expect to use the building five or ten years from now.
A professionally built granny flat can be designed as a proper second living space for family, guests or tenants. That makes the layout and relationship with the main house important from the beginning.
You might initially build for an adult child, for example, and later decide to use the same space for a parent or rental accommodation. A sensible layout gives you more room to adapt without having to rethink the entire building.
The same thinking applies if you are looking at a backyard dwelling as an investment. You need to consider whether the finished space will actually work for the people who may live there, rather than focusing only on the initial construction cost.
What Should You Consider Before Choosing?
Be sure to look at these points before committing to either option:
- Your block and whether access, slope or shape creates building challenges
- Your intended use such as family accommodation, guests or rental income
- The approval pathway available for your property
- The design and whether it gives you enough flexibility
- The total project cost, rather than the advertised starting price
- Who manages the construction and coordinates the different stages
- How useful the building will be later if your circumstances change
This is also where speaking with experienced granny flat builders can be helpful. A site assessment can reveal issues that are difficult to spot when you are simply comparing floor plans online.
So, Are Granny Flats Better Than Kit Homes?
For a homeowner who wants a beautiful backyard home that is designed around the property and intended for long term use, you would generally lean towards a professionally designed and constructed granny flat.
That does not make kit homes a poor choice. They can suit particular projects and budgets. The better option depends on the block, the purpose of the building and how much responsibility you want to take on during the process.
For Sydney and NSW homeowners, the most useful approach is to start with the property rather than the building package. Once you know what your site can accommodate and what you want the space to achieve, the choice becomes much easier.
At Brickwood Homes, we can help you work through that process, from the initial design and site assessment through to approvals and construction. Our team has more than 20 years of experience across building and project management in Sydney and NSW; check out our recent projects like Camden, Botany and Chipping Norton to see how we can build granny flats with exceptional appeal and function.
If you are considering a granny flat, get in touch with our local granny flat builders today to discuss your ideas and what you would like the finished space to achieve.